Ballantine’s 17 Year Old Blended Whisky – The festive dram

I’d like to think I don’t buy into whisky hype as a rule. I buy and enjoy certain whiskies because I try them and like them… not because fashion dictates I do.

Ballantine's 17 Year Old Blended WhiskyHowever, I succumbed this year. Jim Murray’s 2011 world dram of the year and 2012 blend of the year is the Ballantine’s 17 Year old and I had to give it a try.

This was not all about blindly following the guide, though. I am trying to expand my whisky repertoire and the Ballantine’s seemed like a good direction to travel. It promised to be a more subtle Scotch: complex, yet balanced.

In the glass, the Balantine’s has a very pleasing rich golden colour. Give it a swirl and it is noticeably ‘oily’, a characteristic which always reassures.

On the nose, there is almost an alcohol burn but this is quickly replaced by a sharp, citrusy tang and honey, spice and deep down some traces of peat an Islay. The latter takes some digging though.

The oiliness is present in the mouth with a truck load of sweetness, some fresh and zingy, some duller, almost butterscotch. Added to that is a creamy sensation which mellows any of the livelier characteristics.

So far so good, then. However, for me, here the fun stops. I find it hard to trace any other depth after all that sweetness. There’s vanilla after the cream, perhaps, but the initial promise seems to just vaporise. The finish, for me, was a let down.

I’ve tried it in numerous situations, with and without water, and I keep on feeling a bit short-changed.

The Ballantine’s 17 year old is a very civilised whisky that would prompt many a non-Scotch drinker to explore further. However, I would liken it to those grand hotels you find north of the border: manicured lawns, tartan carpets, a round of golf, afternoon tea and dressing for dinner.

After the initial pleasantries, the novelty soon wears off.

3 thoughts on “Ballantine’s 17 Year Old Blended Whisky – The festive dram

  1. As the man said “…there can be no argument about taste”. However, I agree with both Barry and northernwalker – it certainly doesn’t suite my palate. On a more positive note, your postings have prompted me to partake of a post-prandial dram – in this case a 12year old “Highland Park”. I assume you both will have experienced it but, if not, can I suggest you give it a try?


  2. Thanks both for you comments.
    I haven’t tried Highland Park. However, it comes highly recommended by my Scottish friends, as does Macallan – in various guises.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s